Week One in the Books

Checking in on a Sunday night for a quick look at our 1st place Giants, as well as some tidbits about starting pitching around MLB.

Giants – A Whole Lotta Runs

It’s important to get the season off on the right foot. Remember last year’s April slide? Well, 5-2 (good for 1st in the West) ain’t bad at all. When you consider a 1-run loss in Milwaukee and a blown 9th inning lead against the Dodgers are the only blemishes, it’s easy to see that this is one of the hottest clubs in baseball at the moment.

Though the bullpen’s done a pretty nice job of limiting runs, the rotation hasn’t hit full stride so far (Bumgarner’s Saturday notwithstanding). Still, you have to admire Cueto’s tenacity today. All kinds of dinks and dunks plus a ton of bad luck, and he’s looking at a 5-0 hole in the first. Six innings later, he’s pitching with a 9-6 lead. That dude can absolutely pitch, and his teammates had his back today. Would Hudson/Vogey/Lincecum have been able to get back on the bump for 7 innings like that last year after laboring through the first? I’m not so sure.

Anyway, this team is riding an offense that is #1 in MLB runs scored, #2 in homeruns (sometimes spring training trends DO continue!), #5 in OPS, and #6 in walks. This is supposed to be a team of gap hitters, but so far they’re putting the ball over the fence with ease. It’s been fun to watch. You know what else I love about this lineup? They’re 6th in the league with only 36 K’s. Every team above them (Miami is #1 with 30) has played 2 or 3 fewer games. Most lineups who hit the long ball also swing and miss. The Giants are packing the punch without striking out. Now THAT’s impressive.

What About Game Score?

I wrote extensively about pitcher Game Score (GSc) this offseason and have taken on the challenge of calculating it for every starting pitcher in every game this year. Remember, Game Score is an easy to calculate metric (start with 50; add 1 pt for every out; 2 pts for every IP after the 4th; 1 pt for every K; subtract 2 for every hit; 2 for every run; 4 for every earned run; 1 for every BB).

Game Scores are often used to compare dominant outings (particularly no-hitters & perfect games), but very few people have ever used them to compare pitchers (and rotations) over a full season or a career. When IP, ERA, H/9, BB/9, and K/9 are still some of the most prevalent counting stats used to evaluate pitchers, why are we not using a metric that combines all of them into one I ask?

A study was done by Sabr.org in 2007 to show the correlation between specific game scores and team wins. Long story short, a pitcher who earns a score of 55 or higher gives his team at least a 60% chance of winning, while a score of 43 or less lowers the team’s win probably to under 40%. The middle area, that 50/50 spot, falls in the range of 44-54. I use this information to award pitchers with wins (55+ GSc), losses (0-43), and no decisions (44-54).

So, just how has the league fared so far in the eyes of Game Score this season?

MLB Totals: 172 GP, 75 W, 54 L, 43 ND – .436 win% | 50.6 GSc avg

NL Pitchers: 87 GP, 37-31-19 | .425 win%  | 49.8 avg

AL Pitchers: 85 GP, 38-23-24 | .447 win% | 51.4 avg

The league average looks to be pretty close to last year (Baseball-Reference lists it at 52 for 2015). How are the win probabilities holding up so far? Teams whose SP’s earn a 55 or higher (GSc W) are winning at a 71% clip. 44-54 (GSc ND) have a win% of 44%. Scores of 43 or less are winning at only a 26% clip so far.

Top 5 GSc by Team

Royals 60.8 | Dodgers 60.7 | Cubs 60.3 | Phillies 58.3 | Mets 58.2

Bottom 5 by Team

D-Backs 37.9 | Rockies 39.2 | Padres 40.5 | Cardinals 40.8 | Astros 41.8

Giants: 2 W -3 L- 2 ND (49.1 avg)

It’ll be interesting to check back in on these throughout the season. If the trends of the first week continue though, the Giants are going to have a lot of fun scoring runs against NL West pitching. As we get a little farther along, I’ll start posting individual pitcher scores and W/L records. For now, it’s a little too early for that. I do know that Clayton Kershaw leads the Majors with a 76.5 Avg through 2 starts. Zack Greinke? 32 Avg.

After two starts of their own Bumgarner’s average is 54.5, Cueto’s is 52.

Thanks for reading everyone. Here’s to another great week of Giants baseball!



2 thoughts on “Week One in the Books”

  1. Nice wrap up. How are H/9, BB/9, and K/9 counting stats? Shouldn’t those be rate stats? Are you keeping score yourself because you have to? it seems like a number that somebody else must be generating that you could use.

  2. Heya Cove. Gotta love some of the crazy stat lines every “first week of the season.” Dillon Dobson: .818 SLG. 2B, 3B, 3 HR in 22 AB thru 6 games!

    I saw your tweet mentioning Fargas’ three triples in four games (.909 SLG). Whoa.
    Bickford at 19.3 SO/9. Cyr at 18.7. Slania at 18.0. Seriously?
    Ray Black = 22.5 SO/9! Dude, bring it to SF!
    Wait, what’s the math on that? Isn’t it like 5 strikeouts per inning? lol.

I'd love your feedback!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s